Biodegradable products are marketed as eco-friendly alternatives to traditional plastics, but what actually happens to them after disposal? While the term “biodegradable” suggests that these items naturally break down, the reality is more complex. Let’s explore the lifecycle of biodegradable items and the factors that influence their decomposition.
What Does “Biodegradable” Really Mean?
Biodegradable refers to a material’s ability to break down into natural elements like carbon dioxide, water, and biomass through the action of microorganisms such as bacteria and fungi. Unlike traditional plastics that can persist in the environment for centuries, biodegradable items theoretically decompose within a shorter time span. However, this process is heavily dependent on the surrounding conditions.
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defines biodegradability as the breakdown of organic substances by natural means, but it does not specify a time frame or the exact conditions required. This lack of clarity often leads to misconceptions about how quickly biodegradable products decompose and where they should be disposed of.
How Biodegradable Items Break Down
The breakdown of biodegradable products can be influenced by several factors:
• Exposure to Oxygen and Sunlight: Most biodegradable products need ample exposure to oxygen and sunlight to break down. In a natural, outdoor environment like a garden, biodegradable materials might break down over a few months to a few years. However, in a landfill, where items are buried under layers of waste without proper exposure to oxygen, the breakdown process can be significantly delayed.
• Moisture and Heat: For biodegradable items to decompose efficiently, certain moisture and heat levels are essential. Industrial composting facilities often provide these controlled environments, where materials break down within a specific time frame, typically 90 to 180 days. Without these ideal conditions, a product labeled as biodegradable may persist for much longer than expected.
In landfills, the lack of oxygen can prevent proper degradation, leading to anaerobic decomposition, which produces methane, a potent greenhouse gas. This contradicts the environmental benefit intended by using biodegradable products, especially when items are disposed of improperly.
What Happens to Biodegradable Items in Landfills?
Landfills present one of the most challenging environments for biodegradable products to break down. Without sufficient air, sunlight, or moisture, these items may take decades or even centuries to decompose, not much better than conventional plastics. Moreover, biodegradable items in landfills can contribute to methane emissions due to the anaerobic conditions.
According to a study by Zero Waste Europe, items labeled as biodegradable can cause more harm than good if they end up in landfills, as they do not break down as quickly as consumers might expect. This is why proper disposal methods are crucial to realizing the environmental benefits of biodegradable products.
Biodegradable vs. Compostable: A Critical Distinction
It’s important to distinguish biodegradable items from compostable ones. While both are designed to break down over time, compostable products are meant to decompose fully within a certain time frame and leave no toxic residue. Compostable items, such as ZenPacks’ sugarcane bowls and kraft packaging, are best disposed of in industrial composting facilities where they can break down efficiently and contribute to healthy soil.
Biodegradable products, on the other hand, don’t always require specific environmental conditions to break down, but they also don’t guarantee a return of beneficial nutrients to the earth.
Example: A biodegradable plastic fork may take years to break down in a landfill, releasing methane in the process, while a compostable sugarcane bowl can break down in a composting facility in less than 180 days, leaving behind nutrient-rich compost.
Case Study: The Reality of Biodegradable Products in Waste Streams
A 2019 study conducted by WRAP UK, a leading sustainability nonprofit, analyzed the decomposition rates of biodegradable plastics in various environments. The study found that while biodegradable plastics do break down in ideal conditions, when disposed of in landfills or the ocean, the products persisted much longer than expected. The study emphasized the importance of proper waste management and the need for controlled environments to ensure biodegradable products break down as intended.
Similarly, a large-scale trial by the University of Plymouth found that “biodegradable” bags, after three years in soil, were still capable of holding groceries, highlighting how the term “biodegradable” can often mislead consumers about the environmental impact of these products.
The Future of Biodegradable Materials: Opportunities and Challenges
As more companies pivot towards eco-friendly alternatives, innovation in biodegradable materials is on the rise. For instance, scientists are exploring biodegradable plastics derived from plant-based materials such as corn starch or seaweed. These innovations hold the promise of providing more sustainable solutions, but their effectiveness will depend on proper waste management and global infrastructure.
However, the lack of standardization and clarity around what “biodegradable” means remains a challenge. Efforts are underway, with organizations like Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) pushing for clearer labeling and consumer education. Proper disposal systems, such as recycling and composting facilities, also need to expand to accommodate these products better.
How to Properly Dispose of Biodegradable Items
The best way to ensure biodegradable items break down as intended is to follow appropriate disposal guidelines:
• Use Commercial Composting Facilities: If a biodegradable item is labeled as industrially compostable, ensure it’s sent to a commercial composting facility where it can break down under controlled conditions. These facilities provide the optimal heat, moisture, and microorganisms needed for decomposition.
• Avoid Sending to Landfills: If possible, avoid disposing of biodegradable products in regular waste bins, as they are likely to end up in landfills where they will decompose slowly and possibly emit harmful gases.
• Check Local Recycling Programs: Some biodegradable products can be recycled, but always check your local recycling guidelines before disposal.
The Path Forward for Biodegradable Products
While biodegradable products present a more sustainable alternative to traditional plastics, their environmental impact largely depends on how they are disposed of. When placed in the right conditions, such as composting facilities, biodegradable items can break down more quickly and with less environmental harm. However, when these products are improperly discarded, they may contribute to waste problems similar to those caused by conventional plastics.
Understanding the fate of biodegradable items and ensuring proper disposal can go a long way in maximizing their environmental benefits. Companies, consumers, and policymakers must work together to create systems that ensure biodegradable materials are managed in ways that truly benefit the planet.
For more guidance on biodegradable and compostable products, visit ZenPacks for a wide selection of eco-friendly packaging solutions that are designed for both environmental sustainability and practical use.
Comments